Skip to main content
24 ENR

PPA under audit scrutiny. Part 2: Valuation, hedge accounting and auditor-ready documentation

Maciej Krokosiński Oct 6, 2026

Determining whether a PPA falls within the scope of IFRS 9 is only the beginning of the analysis. If the agreement is within the scope of the Standard, the company may need to recognise a financial instrument at fair value. If the PPA is used to hedge electricity price risk, hedge accounting becomes another key consideration. 

Regardless of the accounting approach adopted, the auditor will expect consistent data, verifiable assumptions and documentation prepared on a timely basis. 

This article focuses on IFRS accounting and audit considerations for companies operating in Poland. The specific contractual, regulatory, and electricity-market arrangements relevant to a PPA may differ between jurisdictions. 

In this article, you will find ⬇️ 

  • an explanation of the implications of a PPA falling within the scope of IFRS 9, 

  • an overview of the key elements involved in measuring a PPA at fair value, 

  • guidance on market data, volume forecasts and credit risk, 

  • a description of the areas of a valuation model most commonly examined by auditors, 

  • the principles for preparing and documenting hedge accounting, 

  • information on disclosure requirements for certain electricity contracts, 

  • a list of materials worth including in the auditor-ready documentation package, 

  • examples of issues that can lead to additional questions, delays or adjustments, 

  • the benefits of reviewing the valuation model and documentation before period-end. 

Classification determines what comes next 

In Part 1 of this series, we explained how an auditor may analyse the structure of a PPA, the scope of IFRS 9 and the own-use requirements. The outcome of that assessment determines the next steps. 

If the contract remains outside the scope of IFRS 9, the company should document the basis for its conclusion and monitor whether the way in which the agreement is performed continues to support that conclusion. 

If the contract falls within the scope of IFRS 9, it may be necessary to: 

  • recognise a financial instrument, 

  • determine its fair value, 

  • recognise changes in value in subsequent periods, 

  • assess whether hedge accounting may be applied, 

  • prepare the relevant disclosures. 

A late determination that the agreement should be measured at fair value may mean having to build a valuation model during the audit and recognise an unplanned adjustment to reported earnings. 

Why is PPA valuation challenging? 

A long-term electricity contract cannot usually be valued reliably using a single average price and an annual volume. 

The value of the agreement may depend on: 

  • the remaining contractual term, 

  • the contract price, 

  • market electricity price curves, 

  • market liquidity for more distant periods, 

  • the hourly or monthly generation profile, 

  • the hourly or monthly consumption profile, 

  • differences between the renewable generation profile and the baseload profile, 

  • the delivery location, 

  • basis risk, 

  • balancing costs, 

  • potential negative electricity prices, 

  • generation curtailment, 

  • volume variability, 

  • options embedded in the agreement, 

  • the credit risk of the parties, 

  • the discounting of future cash flows. 

A fixed price specified in the agreement does not mean that the value of the agreement remains fixed. The value of a PPA changes as market conditions, forecasts and other model parameters change. 

What perspective should be applied in the valuation? 

IFRS 13 bases fair value measurement on assumptions that market participants would use under current market conditions. Risk assumptions must also be taken into account. The entity’s own intention to hold or perform the contract does not replace the market-participant perspective. 

In practice, this means that the model should not be based solely on: 

  • the company’s internal budget, 

  • prices used for an investment decision made several years earlier, 

  • the original model used during contract negotiations, 

  • an assumption that the agreement will be performed unchanged until the end of its term. 

Internal data may be relevant, particularly in relation to the consumption profile and operating plans. It is nevertheless necessary to determine the extent to which those data are consistent with assumptions that market participants would use. 

What will the auditor focus on in the fair value model? 

The auditor will want to understand how the model translates the contractual terms into forecast cash flows. 

The analysis may cover five main areas. 

1. Valuation methodology 

The auditor will assess whether the methodology applied is appropriate for the structure of the agreement and the availability of data. 

Questions may include: 

  • Why was this particular valuation technique selected? 

  • How does the model reflect the settlement mechanism? 

  • Have all material contractual provisions been incorporated? 

  • How does the model account for options and contingent features? 

  • Is the methodology applied consistently from one period to another? 

2. Market data 

The following may be subject to verification: 

  • the sources of electricity price curves, 

  • the date on which the data were obtained, 

  • the methodology used to extrapolate prices beyond the liquid market horizon, 

  • location adjustments, 

  • profile adjustments, 

  • assumptions concerning negative prices, 

  • volatility and correlations used to value options. 

Every material parameter should have a traceable and reproducible source. 

3. Generation and consumption forecasts 

The auditor may compare the data used in the valuation with: 

  • the budget, 

  • operating forecasts, 

  • the own-use assessment, 

  • risk management documentation, 

  • models used for impairment testing, 

  • information presented to the company’s management or supervisory bodies. 

Differences do not necessarily indicate an error, but they should be explained. 

4. Credit risk and discounting 

For long-term PPAs, the effect of non-performance risk relating to either party may be material. 

The auditor may assess: 

  • how the discount rate was determined, 

  • assumptions regarding the counterparty’s creditworthiness, 

  • the entity’s own credit risk, 

  • contractual security arrangements, 

  • guarantees, deposits and collateral arrangements, 

  • consistency of the parameters with other valuations performed by the company. 

5. Controls over the model 

Even a correctly designed model can produce incorrect results if appropriate controls are not in place. 

It is worth documenting: 

  • who prepares the valuation, 

  • who approves the input data, 

  • who reviews the formulas, 

  • how changes to the file or valuation tool are managed, 

  • how the valuation result is reconciled to the accounting records, 

  • how changes in value between reporting periods are explained. 

When auditing accounting estimates, the auditor assesses the method, data and assumptions. The greater the estimation uncertainty, model complexity or subjectivity of the parameters, the more extensive the audit evidence that may be required. The audit team may also involve a valuation specialist or an energy market specialist. 

Why is sensitivity analysis necessary? 

Long-term PPAs may be sensitive to changes in several parameters at the same time. 

Sensitivity analysis helps determine how the value of the agreement may be affected by: 

  • changes in the electricity price curve, 

  • changes in expected generation, 

  • changes in the capture-price profile, 

  • higher balancing costs, 

  • an increased frequency of negative electricity prices, 

  • changes in the discount rate, 

  • deterioration in the counterparty’s credit risk. 

For management, this provides information about potential earnings volatility. For the auditor, it is one way of assessing the significance of individual assumptions and the level of estimation uncertainty. 

Can a PPA qualify for hedge accounting? 

Many PPAs are intended, from an economic perspective, to reduce exposure to electricity price risk. A business objective of this kind does not, however, automatically result in the application of hedge accounting. 

IFRS 9 requires the hedging relationship to be formally designated and documented at inception. The documentation should be consistent with the entity’s risk management objective and strategy. It is also necessary to demonstrate an economic relationship between the hedging instrument and the hedged item. 

The work may include: 

  • identifying the hedging instrument, 

  • defining the hedged item, 

  • defining the hedged risk, 

  • describing the risk management objective and strategy, 

  • determining the hedge ratio, 

  • identifying sources of hedge ineffectiveness, 

  • selecting the method for assessing hedge effectiveness, 

  • preparing the accounting treatment, 

  • determining how frequently the hedging relationship will be monitored. 

The documentation should not be postponed until the annual financial statements are prepared. 

Attempting to reconstruct a hedging relationship after the end of the reporting period may fail to satisfy the requirement for formal designation at the inception of the relationship. 

How do the amendments effective from 2026 affect hedge accounting? 

The amendments concerning contracts referencing nature-dependent electricity introduced a specific solution for certain hedging relationships. 

Subject to the relevant conditions, an entity is permitted to designate as the hedged item a variable nominal amount of forecast electricity transactions that is aligned with the variable amount of nature-dependent electricity expected to be delivered by the generation facility referenced in the hedging instrument. 

In specified circumstances, a forecast transaction may also be presumed to be highly probable. 

The remaining hedge accounting requirements continue to apply. 

The amendment may make it easier for the accounting treatment to better reflect the way in which entities manage risks associated with weather-dependent generation volumes. It does not, however, eliminate the need to prepare documentation, measure hedge ineffectiveness and regularly assess the hedging relationship. 

What disclosures may be required? 

The amendments to IFRS 7 introduced additional disclosure requirements for certain contracts referencing nature-dependent electricity. 

Their purpose is to enable users of the financial statements to understand the effects of the agreements on: 

  • the amount of future cash flows, 

  • the timing of those cash flows, 

  • uncertainty associated with those cash flows, 

  • the entity’s financial performance. 

Depending on the type of contract, the disclosures may include: 

  • features that expose the entity to variability in the amount of electricity, 

  • the risk of purchasing electricity that the entity cannot use at the time of delivery, 

  • estimates of future cash flows arising from electricity purchases, 

  • how the entity assesses whether the contract could become onerous, 

  • the costs of electricity purchases, 

  • the amount or cost of electricity that was unused at the time of delivery, 

  • proceeds from the sale of unused electricity, 

  • the costs of subsequent electricity purchases made to offset earlier sales, 

  • information relating to contracts designated as hedging instruments. 

From an organisational perspective, this means determining sufficiently early: 

  • which systems contain the required data, 

  • who is responsible for preparing those data, 

  • whether operational data can be reconciled to the accounting records, 

  • whether the information is available for the correct reporting period, 

  • which controls ensure its completeness. 

A lack of data cannot be solved simply by adding another item to the disclosure checklist. 

What should be included in the auditor-ready documentation package? 

A well-prepared package should allow the auditor to trace the path from the contractual terms to the accounting conclusion and to the amounts reported in the financial statements. 

It may include: 

1. Contractual documentation 

  • the agreement, 

  • amendments, 

  • appendices, 

  • side letters, 

  • confirmations of changes to the contractual terms. 

2. Accounting memorandum 

  • description of the agreement, 

  • IFRS 9 scope assessment, 

  • own-use assessment, 

  • basis for the accounting policy adopted, 

  • assessment of the amendments effective from 2026. 

3. Volume data 

  • generation, 

  • consumption, 

  • deliveries, 

  • sales of surplus electricity, 

  • offsetting purchases, 

  • balancing costs, 

  • reconciliation of the data to source systems. 

4. Fair value model 

  • the calculation file, 

  • description of the methodology, 

  • data sources, 

  • assumptions, 

  • sensitivity analyses, 

  • results of the model review, 

  • reconciliation to the accounting records. 

5. Hedge accounting documentation 

  • formal designation of the hedging relationship, 

  • description of the strategy, 

  • the hedged item and hedged risk, 

  • hedge ratio, 

  • sources of ineffectiveness, 

  • effectiveness assessment, 

  • accounting entries. 

6. Disclosures 

  • draft financial statement note, 

  • disclosure requirements checklist, 

  • source data, 

  • reconciliation with other parts of the financial statements. 

7. Controls 

  • description of the process, 

  • roles and responsibilities, 

  • evidence of review, 

  • approval of input data, 

  • change management relating to the valuation model. 

The most common issues identified during valuation and audit 

1. A model based on a single average price. 

It does not reflect differences between the hours in which renewable electricity is generated and the corresponding market price profile. 

2. Not all contractual provisions are reflected. 

The model omits a floor, cap, negative prices, options, balancing costs or generation curtailment. 

3. No traceable data sources. 

It is not possible to determine where a parameter came from or why it was used. 

4. Inconsistency with the own-use assessment. 

The valuation uses a different volume profile from the one used in the classification memorandum. 

5. Hedge accounting is documented too late. 

The company has an economic hedging objective but has not prepared a timely formal designation of the hedging relationship. 

6. No update process. 

The model is run once a year, and responsibility for updating the data has not been assigned. 

7. Disclosures are prepared without the necessary operational data. 

The finance team receives information on surplus electricity and offsetting purchases too late or in a format that cannot be reconciled. 

8. No explanation of changes in value. 

The company knows the valuation result but cannot attribute the change to prices, volume, the passage of time or credit risk. 

Why does a pre-audit review reduce risk? 

A review performed in advance makes it possible to assess not only the accounting conclusion itself but also the readiness of the underlying process. 

It can enable the company to: 

  • identify the impact of the agreement on profit or loss and the statement of financial position at an earlier stage, 

  • review the valuation model before period-end, 

  • resolve inconsistencies between different data sets, 

  • prepare sensitivity analyses, 

  • complete the hedge accounting documentation, 

  • establish a process for collecting data required for disclosures, 

  • reconcile accounting entries, 

  • prepare responses to anticipated auditor queries, 

  • reduce the number of subsequent versions of documents. 

The greatest risk is not always an incorrect model. Often, it is the lack of sufficient time to explain assumptions, obtain the necessary data and make required adjustments before the financial statements are approved. 

How does Baker Tilly TPA support companies with PPAs in Poland? 

The work can begin with a PPA Quick Diagnostic — a focused review of the agreement, available data and the accounting position adopted to date. 

The result includes: 

  • identification of the most significant risk areas, 

  • a preliminary assessment of the possible accounting classification, 

  • a list of missing information, 

  • a recommendation regarding the scope of further work. 

Depending on the outcome, our support may then include: 

  • an own-use assessment, 

  • an IFRS 9 classification assessment, 

  • preparation or review of a financial instrument valuation, 

  • hedge accounting implementation, 

  • preparation of a technical accounting memorandum, 

  • preparation of draft disclosures, 

  • auditor-ready documentation. 

The project involves experts in IFRS, financial instrument valuation and energy markets. This ensures that the accounting assessment, valuation model and supporting documentation are based on a consistent set of assumptions. 

Summary 

Once it has been determined that a PPA falls within the scope of IFRS 9, the company should prepare to value the agreement and assess its impact on reported earnings. The valuation model needs to reflect the contractual structure, electricity profile, market data, credit risk and contingent features. 

If the PPA is intended to serve as a hedging instrument, hedge accounting requires timely designation of the hedging relationship and documentation that is consistent with the entity’s risk management strategy. 

The auditor will assess the entire information chain: from the contractual terms, through the data and valuation model, to the accounting entries and disclosures. An early review helps organise this process and reduce the risk of adjustments arising only during the final stages of the audit. 

Do you have a signed PPA or are you currently negotiating one? Start with a PPA Quick Diagnostic. 

Contact
Photo of Maciej Krokosiński
Maciej Krokosiński
Partner, Baker Tilly TPA
Looking for expert support?
Request a quote