Skip to main content
25 ENR

PPA under audit scrutiny. Part 1: Does the contract fall within the scope of IFRS 9?

Maciej Krokosiński Sep 29, 2026

A Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) is usually structured around commercial objectives: stabilising energy prices, securing an offtake for generated electricity or securing the supply of renewable electricity. During the financial statement audit, however, the auditor will look at the agreement from a different perspective. The auditor will assess its economic substance, how it is actually performed and the data supporting the accounting treatment adopted. A small number of provisions relating to volume, surplus electricity, balancing arrangements or the pricing formula may determine whether IFRS 9 applies, whether fair value measurement is required and how the agreement affects profit or loss. 

In this article, you will find ⬇️

  • an explanation of when a PPA may fall within the scope of IFRS 9,
  • guidance on how to assess whether the own-use requirements are met,
  • an overview of the importance of the renewable generation profile and the electricity consumption profile,
  • examples of contractual provisions that may affect the classification of a PPA,
  • a discussion of the amendments effective from 1 January 2026 for certain contracts referencing nature-dependent electricity,
  • a list of data and documents that an auditor may request,
  • the most common weaknesses in PPA assessments prepared by companies,
  • reasons for reviewing the agreement before the audit begins. 

Why can a PPA become a significant audit area? 

A long-term electricity contract combines several elements that are relevant to financial reporting:

  • the term of the agreement,
  • the pricing formula,
  • the generation profile of the renewable energy source,
  • the offtaker’s electricity consumption profile,
  • the rules for settling surpluses and shortfalls,
  • responsibility for balancing,
  • the possibility of financial settlement of the contract,
  • the credit risk of the parties.

The first step is to determine whether the PPA qualifies for the own-use exception applicable to contracts for the purchase or sale of electricity, or whether it falls within the scope of IFRS 9 and should be accounted for as a financial instrument.

IFRS 9 applies to contracts to buy or sell non-financial items that can be settled net in cash or in another manner appropriate for financial instruments. An exception applies to contracts that were entered into and continue to be held for the purpose of receiving or delivering a non-financial item in accordance with the entity’s expected purchase, sale or usage requirements. This is commonly referred to as the own-use exception. 

Where will the auditor start when analysing a PPA? 

The starting point will not be the name of the agreement or the description used in a management presentation. The auditor will want to understand the economic mechanics of the transaction.

In practice, the analysis may include the following questions:

  • Is it a physical PPA, a virtual PPA or a sleeved PPA?
  • Is the volume fixed or does it depend on the actual output of the generation facility?
  • Is the contract structured on a pay-as-produced, baseload or scheduled-delivery basis?
  • Is the offtaker required to take all electricity generated?
  • What happens to electricity that the offtaker cannot use?
  • Who is responsible for balancing?
  • Are shortfalls and surpluses settled physically or financially?
  • Is the price fixed, indexed or subject to a floor or cap?
  • How are negative electricity prices treated?
  • Does the contract include options to change the volume, extend the term or terminate the agreement early?
  • How are Guarantees of Origin (GOs) and other energy-related rights treated?

Individual clauses should not be assessed in isolation. What matters is how all elements of the agreement interact to determine the flows of electricity and cash. 

A physical PPA does not always mean own-use 

One common simplification is to assume that a contract providing for physical delivery of electricity automatically falls outside the scope of IFRS 9.

Physical settlement alone, however, is not sufficient to support the own-use exception. It is also necessary to analyse the possibility of net settlement, the actual purpose for which the agreement was entered into and how it is performed in practice.

Relevant circumstances may include situations where:

  • the entity regularly sells a significant proportion of the electricity it receives,
  • the contracted generation volume significantly exceeds expected consumption,
  • the settlement mechanism effectively results in financial settlement of price differences,
  • the company has a practice of closing out contracts before delivery,
  • the contractual terms make it possible to realise gains arising from changes in electricity prices.

Each case requires an assessment of the specific agreement and the circumstances in which it is performed.

A virtual PPA generally requires particular attention because its core mechanism involves settlement of the difference between the contract price and the market price. This does not mean, however, that all contracts in this category should be accounted for in the same way. The auditor will assess the full set of rights and obligations of the parties. 

Own-use trzeba poprzeć danymi

Management’s intention may be a starting point for the assessment. It does not, however, replace evidence demonstrating that the contract was entered into and continues to be held in accordance with the entity’s expected requirements.

The auditor may ask:

  • what the entity’s historical electricity consumption has been,
  • how consumption varies by hour, month and season,
  • how the offtaker’s consumption profile compares with the generation profile of the wind or solar facility,
  • how frequently surpluses arise,
  • what proportion of unused electricity is sold,
  • whether, after selling surplus electricity, the company subsequently purchases electricity in the same market,
  • whether forecasts are consistent with the budget, production plans and the energy management strategy,
  • whether the way in which the agreement is actually performed remains consistent with the earlier accounting memorandum.

An own-use position should therefore combine an analysis of the agreement with an analysis of operational data. 

What changed from 1 January 2026? 

For annual reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026, amendments to IFRS 9 and IFRS 7 concerning contracts referencing nature-dependent electricity apply. These are contracts under which the amount of electricity varies because generation depends on conditions outside the entity’s control, such as weather. The amendments should not be applied by analogy to other types of contracts.

For entities applying IFRS as adopted by the European Union, the amendments have also been endorsed for use in the EU under Commission Regulation (EU) 2025/1266.

For certain contracts to buy nature-dependent electricity, sales of unused electricity do not necessarily preclude application of the own-use requirements. This may be the case where the design and operation of the electricity market require surplus electricity to be sold and the entity has been, and expects to be, a net purchaser of electricity over the contract period.

In determining whether an entity is a net purchaser, reasonable and supportable information about past, current and expected future transactions should be considered. For historical transactions, the “reasonable amount of time” considered must not exceed 12 months.

The amendments do not eliminate the need for analysis. On the contrary, they increase the importance of maintaining records of:

  • electricity that was unused at the time of delivery,
  • sales of that electricity,
  • subsequent purchases made to offset earlier sales,
  • the reasons why surpluses arise,
  • the seasonality of generation and demand. 

Why can annual volume lead to the wrong conclusion? 

Two agreements may provide for the same annual electricity volume while producing different accounting outcomes.

For example, an industrial company may consume more electricity over the course of a year than the volume generated under its PPA. This does not necessarily mean that it is able to use all of the electricity in each delivery interval.

Solar generation is concentrated in particular hours of the day and months of the year. Wind generation depends on different weather conditions. The offtaker’s demand, in turn, may depend on the number of production shifts, sales seasonality, planned shutdowns or planned investments.

For this reason, the auditor may expect data at a more granular level than the total annual MWh figure. Depending on the structure of the agreement, hourly, daily, monthly or seasonal profiles may be required.

The level of granularity should correspond to the delivery and settlement mechanics provided for in the agreement. 

What about agreements on the producer or seller side? 

The specific requirements for determining whether an entity is a net purchaser apply to certain contracts to buy nature-dependent electricity.

A producer or seller still needs to perform an assessment under the general requirements of IFRS 9, taking into account its expected sales requirements.

The specific net-purchaser requirements should not automatically be extended to the seller side or to other contracts.

In practice, this means determining, among other things:

  • whether the volume covered by the PPA corresponds to expected generation,
  • whether the producer has a practice of buying electricity to fulfil the agreement,
  • how the contract relates to the producer’s remaining sales portfolio,
  • whether the volume commitments are fixed or depend on the output of the generation facility,
  • whether the way in which the agreement is performed remains consistent with the original purpose for entering into it. 

What documents can you expect on the auditor’s request list? 

The scope will depend on the materiality of the agreement and the accounting classification adopted. At a minimum, however, it is worth preparing:

  • the executed agreement together with amendments, appendices and any side arrangements,
  • a description of the physical and financial flows arising from the PPA,
  • a summary of the key contractual terms,
  • an assessment of the possibility of net settlement,
  • an accounting memorandum covering the scope of IFRS 9 and the own-use assessment,
  • historical data on generation, consumption and sales of surplus electricity,
  • forecasts covering the remaining term of the agreement,
  • an explanation of the sources of the forecasts and the process for their approval,
  • a reconciliation of the data to the budget, operating plan and accounting systems.

A description of any changes to the agreement or the manner in which it is performed since the previous assessment was prepared.

When auditing significant accounting estimates, the auditor focuses on the method, data and assumptions and applies professional scepticism. For this reason, the conclusion in an accounting memorandum may not be sufficient if the underlying data cannot be traced and reproduced. 

The most common weaknesses in PPA assessments 

  1. Classification based on the name of the agreement. The fact that an agreement is described as a “physical PPA” does not in itself justify application of the own-use exception. 
  2. Analysis performed only at annual level. An annual electricity total may conceal recurring surpluses in shorter delivery intervals.
  3. No data on unused electricity. The company knows how much electricity it purchased but cannot identify how much was subsequently sold or why.
  4. Different forecasts used by different departments. Treasury, controlling, the energy team and the accounting function use different versions of the data.
  5. The memorandum is not updated following changes to the agreement. An amendment affecting price, volume, balancing arrangements or termination provisions may change the previous conclusion.
  6. No comparison of forecasts with actual performance. The accounting position was prepared when the agreement was signed but is not subsequently verified against actual data.
  7. The analysis begins only during the final stages of the audit. At that point, there may not be enough time to collect detailed volume profiles, prepare a valuation or align the position across the group. 

Why is it worth reviewing the agreement before the audit? 

An early review helps determine which questions need to be resolved and which data should start being collected.

This allows the company to:

  • understand the potential accounting treatment of the agreement earlier,
  • identify contractual provisions requiring additional analysis,
  • prepare an own-use assessment,
  • align forecasts across the organisation,
  • establish a process for recording surplus electricity and offsetting purchases,
  • assess whether a financial instrument valuation will be required,
  • reduce the risk of adjustments being prepared under time pressure,
  • respond more efficiently to auditor queries.

A review performed before the PPA is signed provides the greatest flexibility. At this stage, the accounting implications can still be considered when negotiating provisions relating to volume, surpluses, balancing arrangements and pricing.

If the agreement has already been signed, a review before period-end can still help organise the data and prepare the supporting rationale before the audit begins. 

Summary 

The classification of a PPA does not depend on a single contractual provision or merely on the fact that electricity is physically delivered. The auditor will analyse the structure of the agreement, the possibility of net settlement, how the agreement is performed and whether the contracted volume is consistent with the entity’s expected requirements. 

Data are critical. They should support the conclusion reached in relation to IFRS 9 and the own-use assessment. 

In Part 2 of this series, we explain what happens once the classification of the agreement has been determined: how a PPA is valued, what the auditor will expect from the valuation model, when hedge accounting may be applied, and how to prepare the supporting documentation and disclosures. 

Contact
Photo of Maciej Krokosiński
Maciej Krokosiński
Partner, Baker Tilly TPA
Looking for expert support?
Request a quote